Down (feather) mattress toppers review

We’ve reviewed most of the down (feather) mattress toppers available on the market(read about our accurate unbiased method), compared them side-by-side, and scored them according to a range of factors including comfort, pain relief potential, durability, initial odor and heat retention ability.

Below you will find a comparison table(click on the product name to read full review).

Top ranked down feather toppers How We Test

Our Ranking #1 #2 #3
Product Name
White Goose Feather Baffle Featherbed Topper
Overstuffed Feather Pillow Mattress Topper
Mattress Topper Featherbed Feather Baffled Topper
Editors’ Awards editors choice
Price $69
Buy at Amazon
$200
Buy at Amazon
$119
Buy at Amazon
Overall Score
100
0
56
100
0
53
100
0
50
Editors’ Rating 4.5 Stars 4.2 Stars 4 Stars
User Rating 4.2 Stars 4.7 Stars 4 Stars
Date Reviewed April 12, 2015 April 12, 2015 April 12, 2015
Scores White Goose Feather Baffle Featherbed Topper Overstuffed Feather Pillow Mattress Topper Mattress Topper Featherbed Feather Baffled Topper
Comfort
10
0
6
10
0
6
10
0
5
Pain relief
10
0
5
10
0
5
10
0
5
Durability
10
0
5
10
0
6
10
0
5
No bad odor
10
0
6
10
0
6
10
0
5
No sleeping hot
10
0
9
10
0
8
10
0
7
Easy to maintain
10
0
4
10
0
3
10
0
4
Easy to clean
10
0
4
10
0
3
10
0
4
Read the Review
Read the Review
Read the Review
White Goose Feather Baffle Featherbed Topper

Read the Review

100
0
56
editors choice

$69
Buy at Amazon

Overstuffed Feather Pillow Mattress Topper
Read the Review
100
0
53

$200
Buy at Amazon

Mattress Topper Featherbed Feather Baffled Topper
Read the Review
100
0
50

$119
Buy at Amazon

Featherbed, down or feather mattress toppers are a common name of a soft mattress topper that is manufactured with the use of bird’s down and feathers. As down/feather mattress toppers are the softest option available, they are used to add softness to hard and firm mattress. These are lightweight toppers that are easy to carry.

How it is Constructed?

Featherbed/Down mattress toppers are usually made up of combination of geese and duck feathers and down usually found under their feathers to maintain loft. Feathers made the bulk of the filling with down as a smaller portion.

Health and Safety

Even though, featherbed toppers are not effective for back and shoulder pain relief but they are reported mostly effective for minimizing pressure points. If you are using hypoallergenic cotton cover, they are also effective for people with allergy. Feather quills can pop up and can cause pain after regular use.

Firmness

Featherbed/Down mattress toppers are considered as the softest toppers. They are not firm enough as support and loft is often lacking. They are not a good fit for people with weight as it compresses under the weight.

Pros

User’s feedback about its ability to minimize pressure points is above average. They are also very easy to move around. Heating issues are also not reported with very few complaints about heat trap. The biggest advantage is their light weight that makes them very easy to carry. They can also fit properly to the bed and don’t sleep around. Complaints about initial odor are also less than latex and memory foam toppers. Durability and longevity is also rated moderately if not highly praised.

Cons

They are not easy to maintain and clean. They often lose their shape and require constant fluffing and movement to maintain proper shape and loft. Machine wash can make them lumpy and can significantly reduce their life. They also fail to isolate the motion and often considered unfriendly if you are sharing with your partner. Complaints about popping quills and loss of loft with time are also reported.

Lifespan and Warranty

Lifespan and warranty is almost similar to other common types that is 3 to 5 years, but users have complained about reduced loft and thickness with time and quills of feathers popping up usually after shaking.

Cleaning and Maintenance

Featherbed/Down mattress toppers are usually not easy to maintain and clean as machine wash can considerably reduce their life. Only dry cleaning is recommended. It is also required to fluff and shake to keep their loft.

Price Range

Price is average if compared to other topper types. You can find a featherbed topper for $55 as well as for $400. On an average, users can find a good quality topper for $110-$120.

How to Choose?

There are plenty of options to choose from if you are buying featherbed toppers. You can check the ratio of feather and down before buying. For more loft, you may require a topper with greater share of down. Different prices and variation in thickness is also available.

White Goose Feather Baffle Featherbed Topper

The White Goose Feather and Down Baffle Box Featherbed is manufactured by a US based brand, Sweet Jojo Designs. The topper is available in...

Overstuffed Feather Pillow Mattress Topper

The Overstuffed Feather Pillow Mattress Topper is introduced by a renowned bedding brand, Baffle Box Beds. The queen size topper comes in Baffle Box...

Mattress Topper Featherbed Feather Baffled Topper

The 5 inch thick Featherbed Topper is manufactured by Millsave and consists of 95% of goose feather and 5% of goose down. The topper...