Best Down Alternative Pillows

We’ve analyzed 512 reviews of down alternative pillows and compared them side-by-side, scored according to a range of factors including comfort, pain relief potential, durability, initial odor and heat retention ability.

Below you will find comparison chart.

Here Are The Top Picks

Our Ranking #1 #2 #3
Product NameSable Pillows for Sleeping
Sable Pillows for Sleeping
National Sleep Products Premier Personal Choice Density Pillows
National Sleep Products Premier Personal Choice Density Pillows
Blissful Serenity Bamboo Down Alternative Pillow
Blissful Serenity Bamboo Down Alternative Pillow
Price$28
GET BEST PRICE
$43
GET BEST PRICE
$29
GET BEST PRICE
Overall Score
100
0
79
100
0
76
100
0
74
Awardseditors choice
Scores
Owner Satisfaction
10
0
7
10
0
8
10
0
9
Durability
10
0
7
10
0
8
10
0
6
Neck Pain Relief
10
0
8
10
0
8
10
0
8
Moldable
10
0
8
10
0
7
10
0
7
Scrunchable
10
0
9
10
0
8
10
0
7
No Noise
10
0
8
10
0
8
10
0
6
No Odor
10
0
8
10
0
6
10
0
8
Not Hot
10
0
8
10
0
8
10
0
8

Everyone wants a soft pillow to cradle their head at night, however not many are willing to shell hundreds for a down pillow. This is where the down alternative pillow comes in: for a fraction of the price, it can definitely give the same lofty sensation night after night. Let’s have a closer look at these products!

Key Features

There are several points setting these pillows apart from other pillow models. For starters, they are feather-free which makes them a great choice for vegans. A direct effect of no animal produce being used is that the risks of respiratory allergies flaring becomes minimal.

Pros
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Vegan
  • Soft
  • More affordable
  • Easier to care for
Cons
  • Need to be replaced more often
  • Less durable

Important Considerations

Before you go make a purchase, you should know a few details about the down-alternative pillows.

Price

There’s no doubt these pillows are really affordable. This is awesome for those with a tighter budget, but they can prove to be a bigger expense in the long run if their quality is poor. To make sure you’ll be happy with your purchase, check out the product in a store in addition to reading reviews.

Allergy free

Most people who experience a respiratory allergy on a traditional down pillow usually react to dust mites that live inside the pillow. This usually happens with older pillows or products made on the cheap without the down being washed. A down-alternative model minimizes this risk or removes it fully.

Comfort

Most models come with a cotton cover that makes the item pleasant to the touch. What’s more, a cotton cover is also good for decreasing allergy risks.

Generally these pillows are very comfortable to sleep on, no matter your preferred position. They also retain less heat than memory foam models. There’s not much difference between down and down alternative pillows in this regard.

Maintenance

Many models of fiberfill pillows don’t have a zipper that allows you to wash the cover. Most manufacturers say their products are safe to clean in the laundry machine, but you really shouldn’t do that. Water, detergent, and spinning can cause the fill to clump together irrevocably and thus means a ruined pillow.

Fiberfill is less likely to escape through the cover or the sewing when compared to down filled models. This aspect is probably debatable on low quality items.

Durability

These types of pillows don’t have the same long lifespan like other models. Fiberfill is more likely to get pressed down due to regular use, with some folks noticing a big difference after half a year. This means they need to be replaced more often than other type of pillows.

Eco-friendly

There are 2 aspects to consider here. The down alternative pillows are more eco-friendly from a vegan point of view since their filling hasn’t been provided by an animal. At the same time, they can badly pollute the environment if replaced every year.

Top 10 Best Down Alternative Pillows to Consider

Let’s have a look at a selection of pillows you could get, if you wanted to change your current one.

Sable Pillows for Sleeping

Sable Pillows for SleepingThis is a set of 2 pillows specially designed for side sleeping. However their covers have a hidden zipper that allows you to remove or to add filling to adjust both the height or the firmness of the product. The zipper also allows you to easily wash the cover only if you’re scared of ruining the filling.

This is hypoallergenic product as the cover is made entirely of knitted cotton. This feature increases the pillows’ breathability. You’ll receive them all rolled up, but they expand in no time. None of the previous buyers noticed any unpleasant scents coming from the item. They do recommend using pillow cases to protect the cover.

Pros
  • Set of 2
  • Customizable height
  • Budget friendly
Cons
  • Rather heavy
  • Need pillow cases

Blissful Serenity Bamboo Down Alternative Pillow

Blissful Serenity Bamboo Down Alternative PillowThis product has a removable bamboo cover that helps with maintaining an ideal temperature during sleep. You can also easily clean the cover in the machine and then tumble dry it. The pillow’s thickness is easy to adjust as needed.

Customers claim the pillow has the right thickness for both back and side sleeping. Stomach sleepers might want to remove some of the filling first. If you’re not happy with your purchase, you have a 30 day window to return the product.

The consumer reports indicate one can’t be sure of what they will get. Some shoppers received a too fluffy product while others received a pillow that never fluffed up.

Pros
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Very affordable
  • Lightweight
Cons
  • Poor quality control of the finished product

National Sleep Products Premier Personal Choice Density Pillows

National Sleep Products Premier Personal Choice Density PillowsHere you get not one, but 2 pillows which can only be inconvenient if you lack storage room. The pillows are a really good choice for those with sensitive skin as they’re made of a mix of cotton and poly-fiber. You’re still advised to use a pillow case to protect the item.

This model has a medium level of firmness, meaning a 22-ounce fill weight. The cotton cover has a 230 thread count, indicating a decent quality. Previous buyers suggest these pillows are a good idea for occasional use and back sleeping.

Pros
  • Set of 2
  • Very affordable
Cons
  • Need pillow cases

Langria Luxury Hotel Collection Pillows

LangriaThis is again an offer of 2 pillows, which is great for those with a tight budget. These Langria pillows are a better choice for consumers who love soft pillows, as anyone else would feel suffocated by them. This model springs back to fluffines once you get up, a feature many people enjoyed.

These pillows don’t come with protective cases, and they also don’t have zippers to allow you to modify the filling amount. Many buyers complained how the pillows don’t have a consistent amount of filling.

Pros
  • Set of 2
  • Lightweight
  • Very affordable
Cons
  • Need pillow cases
  • Not zippered

White Classic Fiber Filled Pillows

White Classic Fiber Filled PillowsIt’s recommended to allow these pillow to expand before use, for up to 3 days. The process could be faster in a tumble dry machine. They’re free of any fire retardant chemicals that could endanger your health, so they’ll easily catch fire.

Buyers don’t seem to agree on whether the pillows are too puffy or too flat, since everyone has different needs. Side sleepers might need more support than what this model offers. Some customers noted they’re not really true to size as they didn’t fit the pillow cases made for their size.

Pros
  • 2 pieces
  • Lightweight
  • Free of harmful substances
  • Very affordable
Cons
  • Flammable
  • Need pillow cases

Utopia Bedding Fiber Filled Pillows

Utopia Bedding Fiber Filled PillowsThis product has a nice design with stripes, however you still need to use pillow cases on top. Despite being advertised as safe to wash in the machine or preferably by hand, it would be better not to. Washing might cause the fiberfill to clump together.

Most buyers found them to be too tall or with the right firmness. The satisfied customers proceeded with praising these pillows for how comfortable they are. Only very few were disappointed and described them as being too thin.

The cover is made of cotton which adds to the pillows’ comfort. These are delivered compressed and you’re advised to let them expand for a day before use. Many clients were impressed with just how fast the decompression happened, without any waiting period.

Pros
  • 2 pieces
  • Really low price
  • Fast decompression
Cons
  • Heavier than other similar models
  • Need pillow cases

Pillowflex Polyester Filled Pillow

Pillowflex Polyester Filled PillowThis is a squared pillow, and is sold as a single item, not a set of 2 like other models we presented. Keep this in mind if you need more than 1 pillow or you have rectangle cases.

This product hasn’t been treated with any harmful substances and doesn’t smell either. Many clients purchased this item to use with decorative pillow covers and not to actually sleep on, mostly because of its shape.

Pros
  • Lightweight
  • Free of chemicals
Cons
  • Not zippered
  • Not a set

Utopia Bedding Gusseted Quilted Pillow

Utopia Bedding Gusseted Quilted PillowUtopia Bedding has another pair of good pillows to offer, designed for both back and side sleeping. These pillows have a gusset insert on the edge for aesthetic reasons. The blue gusset is on the dark side and can be seen through some pillowcases, something that not everyone appreciates.

The manufacturer recommends you dry clean them, but by using a pillowcase on top this is not needed. Some customers said they washed these at home and that they noticed no damage to the filling. Airing them in the sun when possible also helps with keeping them in shape for longer.

Like most other products on this list, these pillows also arrive vacuum sealed and you need to follow the instructions on how to expand them.

Pros
  • Free of harmful chemicals
  • Low price
  • Soft
Cons
  • Not adjustable
  • Dry cleaning only

Beautyrest Power Pillow

Beautyrest Power PillowThis product is advertised as specifically designed for those who sleep on their sides. The gusset on the edge is a clear indication of this construction, just like in the previous model. The description mentions these pillows offer extra firm support, but not all the customers found this to be true for their needs.

The edge insert is still white in color, with the brand’s name written in silver. You won’t have to worry about this detail being noticeable through the cover. The cover is made of cotton, to prevent allergies.

Pros
  • Best for side sleepers
  • Set of 2
  • 3 available sizes
Cons
  • No zippers
  • Need pillow cases

Equinox International Bed Pillows

Equinox International Bed PillowsThe description mentions these pillows are covered in cotton, however several buyers noticed the tag saying these are made entirely of polyester. Despite this letdown, there are reports that the fabric feels like velvet. Many customers describe these as very fluffy even after months of use.

Side sleepers also found it to be supportive enough through the night as they didn’t need to rearrange or puff it up again. While the seller it’s safe to wash the product in the laundry machine, it’s best not to and use a pillowcase to protect it instead.

Pros
  • Very budget friendly
  • Set of 2
  • No shift design
Cons
  • Heavier than other models
  • Not adjustable

Conclusion

We consider the first product on our list, the Sable Pillows for Sleeping, as the best choice for anyone who needs to replace their pillows. Not only you’ll get a set of 2, you can safely adjust the filling in them to make them more or less firm, according to your needs. This also means that they can be used by anyone, no matter their preferred sleeping position.

These pillow look really nice on their own thanks to the quilted cotton cover with a dark blue hem. They have a zipper allowing you to wash the cover, however you might want to use an extra case for protection.

This product comes with a Class 1 medical device certification from FDA and both the filling and the cover are hypoallergenic and antimicrobial. None of the other products have this certification, so pay attention to this aspect if it’s one you care about.

Please share
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply: